We are not solicitors. This site is free information only. We do not take claims, we do not pass your details to anyone, and we never ask you to sign anything. Who we are

No win, no fee: what it really costs

The widely repeated 25% cap does not apply to most disrepair claims. Here is what the rules actually say, with the sections, so you can check it yourself.

This page applies to England. The law is different in Wales, where Awaab's Law does not apply at all. See our Wales guidance.

The thing most people get wrong

The 25% cap is a personal injury cap. It is not a housing disrepair cap.

It comes from article 5 of the Conditional Fee Agreements Order 2013, which applies to a "claim for personal injuries". If your disrepair claim does not plead an injury, it falls outside that definition, and there is no statutory limit at all expressed as a percentage of your damages.

The two kinds of agreement, and what each can take

Conditional fee agreement (CFA) Damages-based agreement (DBA)
What you pay on a win The solicitor's base fees plus a success fee, which is an uplift on those fees A percentage of what you recover, regardless of hours worked
The cap, disrepair only Success fee up to 100% of base fees Up to 50% of everything recovered, including VAT
The cap, with personal injury 25% of general damages for pain and suffering plus past financial loss, at first instance

That 50% figure is not a worst case someone invented. It is regulation 4(3) of the Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013, and it is the lawful ceiling in a claim that is not for personal injuries.

And no regulator fills the gap

The Solicitors Regulation Authority's fee caps apply to financial services claims management. The Financial Conduct Authority's caps apply to financial services and financial product claims. Housing disrepair sits outside both. What remains is general: fees must be fair and reasonable under the SRA Codes, you can ask for a solicitor-client costs assessment, and you can complain to the Legal Ombudsman.

The costs risk if you lose

In a personal injury claim, Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting means the losing claimant normally does not pay the other side's costs. It is set out in CPR 44.13, and it applies to proceedings that include a claim for damages for personal injuries.

A disrepair-only claim is outside it entirely. Not partially. Entirely.

So if you lose a disrepair claim with no injury element, the ordinary rule in CPR 44.2 applies and you can be ordered to pay the landlord's legal costs. Those costs are not capped, because disrepair claims are excluded from the fixed recoverable costs regime under CPR 45.1(4).

Where a claim includes an injury, it is more complicated

The costs protection applies, but the automatic part of it falls away, because the disrepair element is a claim the protection does not cover. That was decided in Brown v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis (2019). In practice the Court of Appeal expected most genuinely injury-led cases to end up costs-neutral, but it refused to make that a rule.

What comes out of your damages on a win

  1. The success fee or the DBA percentage

    Since April 2013 the success fee cannot be recovered from the landlord. It comes out of your money.

  2. The insurance premium

    Also not recoverable from the landlord since April 2013. Usually deferred so it is only paid on a win, but confirm that in writing.

  3. Any disbursements not recovered

    The surveyor's report, court fees, counsel's fees. Under the protocol a single joint expert's fee is split equally between the parties.

The small claims trap

A tenant's claim for an order for repairs goes to the small claims track where the repairs are estimated at not more than £1,000 and any other damages claim is not more than £1,000. That is CPR 26.9(1)(b), and it catches a great many ordinary disrepair cases.

On the small claims track, legal costs are not generally recoverable between the parties. So a solicitor acting on a modest disrepair claim cannot recover much from the landlord, and the economics only work by taking a share of your damages. That is precisely the situation where the free routes are the better answer.

Questions to ask before you sign anything

  • Is this a conditional fee agreement or a damages-based agreement?
  • What percentage do you take, and of what exactly?
  • Is a personal injury claim being pleaded? If not, you are outside the 25% cap
  • Is After The Event insurance being taken out, who pays the premium, and when?
  • If I lose, what could I be asked to pay, and what exactly does the insurance cover?
  • What happens if I change my mind or change solicitor? What is the cancellation fee?
  • Is this claim likely to be allocated to the small claims track?
  • Have you advised me about the Housing Ombudsman, which is free?

Ask for the answers in writing. A firm acting properly will have no difficulty with that.

Legal aid may be available, and nobody mentions it

Legal aid remains available for housing cases where there is a serious risk of harm to health or safety from a deficiency in the home. That is paragraph 35 of Schedule 1 to the LASPO Act 2012. "Deficiency" is wider than disrepair and expressly includes things like condensation damp caused by poor design. Health includes mental health, and harm includes temporary harm.

It is aimed at getting the work done rather than at winning damages, and funding can stop if the expert report does not support a serious risk. But it is free, and if a claims company has approached you, they will not have told you it exists.

Before any of this The free route, which costs you nothing

Common questions

Is there a 25% cap on what a solicitor can take from a disrepair claim?

Not in a disrepair-only claim. The 25% cap is set by the Conditional Fee Agreements Order 2013 and it applies to claims for personal injuries. A disrepair claim with no injury pleaded falls outside it. In that case there is no statutory limit expressed as a percentage of your damages at all. If a firm tells you they take 25%, that is their own commercial choice, not a legal ceiling.

What is the most a no win no fee agreement can take?

It depends which kind of agreement it is. Under a conditional fee agreement the success fee is capped at 100% of the solicitor’s own base fees, which is not a percentage of your damages and can work out at very different amounts. Under a damages-based agreement in a claim that is not for personal injuries, regulation 4(3) of the Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013 permits up to 50% of everything recovered, including VAT.

If I lose, do I have to pay the landlord’s costs?

Potentially yes. Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting, which protects claimants in personal injury cases, does not apply to a disrepair-only claim at all. The ordinary rule applies and the loser normally pays. This is usually covered by After The Event insurance, but you need to check that the policy exists, is in force, and actually covers it.

Who pays for the insurance?

You do. Since April 2013 an After The Event premium cannot be recovered from the landlord. In practice most policies are deferred and self-insuring, meaning the premium is only payable if you win and comes out of your damages, but that is a market arrangement rather than a legal guarantee. Read the policy.

Does pleading a personal injury make my position better or worse?

Counter-intuitively, it can improve your protection on fees. A claim that includes personal injury falls within the 25% cap and within the costs-shifting rules, where a disrepair-only claim falls outside both. That is not a reason to invent an injury, and adding one brings its own complications, but it explains why the funding position can look odd.